April 24, 2024

A Referendum on Decency

On one my favorite podcasts, “The Ezra Klein Show,” Ezra’s guest on podcast #352 was Stuart Stephens, a former high-level Republican consultant, who said that what the upcoming election boiled down to was “a referendum on decency.”

While I watched the Democratic convention, the one word that I heard more than any other (with the obvious exception of “Joe”) was “decent.” In a “Five Thirty Eight” podcast that discussed the convention, one analyst said that the Democrats had nominated “a decent guy who everyone can relate to.”

In previous blog posts I have emphasized the concept of decency. In a post titled “The Cancel Culture Is Illiberal” I wrote “Instead of a list of ideas that should be excluded from a free-expression dialogue, I believe a broad concept should be applied — decency.” In a blog post titled “What Is The Future of the Republican Party?” I ended the post with “Will the future of the Republican party be driven by hate speech or decency?”

I’m convinced that the presidential election is absolutely a referendum on decency, and my point of view was reinforced by the title of Maureen Dowd’s most recent column titled “Joe’s Fearsome Weapon Against Trump: Simple Decency.”

So be it.

Trump Talk Radio

On April 15, Elaina Plott wrote an article in The New York Times titled “Trump Wanted a Radio Show, but He Didn’t Want to Compete With Limbaugh.”  The article detailed how in early March Trump wanted to do a talk show in which he would take calls and answer questions about the coronavirus pandemic.  However, the show never materialized, in part because Trump didn’t want to compete with his ardent supporter, Rush Limbaugh.

But just for a few chuckles, let’s assume the counterfactual and that the president went ahead with his plan for doing Trump Talk Radio.  Here’s how it might go:

CALLER #1: “Thank you for taking my call.  Can you hear me?”

TRUMP: “Yes, yes.  My hearing is perfect.  Perfect.  I have the best ears in the world.  Much better ears than that awful Obama, whose ears are too big.  Doesn’t he look terrible on TV?”

CALLER #2: “I live in Queens, the hardest hit area in the country, where 60 percent of the inhabitants are people of color.  Can you explain why such a high percent of coronavirus deaths are people of color?”

TRUMP: “Of course I can explain that.  I’m a genius – a stable genius.  People of color are dying in such high numbers because they’re Democrats.  The Democrats had a witch hunt and impeached me and then they hyped up this Chinese virus stuff just to try to make me look bad, so Democrats deserve to die.  Let’s take another call.”

CALLER #3: “A Washington Post story indicated that you wanted to open up the country and get people back to work because you’re in the hotel business and want people to start traveling and booking hotel rooms again.”

TRUMP: “Oh, come on, be nice!  The Washington Post is FAKE NEWS!  It’s owned by that shiny-headed moron, Jeff Bezos.  Amazon doesn’t pay the Post Office enough and is responsible for the Post Office’s $13 billion deficit.  It’s not my fault.  Also, I’m not involved in my business.  Donald junior and Eric are running my business.  They’re doing a beautiful job.  Next caller.”

CALLER #4: “Isn’t it true that your business has a $300-million-dollar payment due soon to Deutsche Bank and that your business can’t make the payment unless your hotels and golf clubs have revenue coming in?”

TRUMP: “How did you get in, dummy.  Be nice.  Ask nice questions about the flu bug.  The fact is that Deutsche Bank didn’t lend me any money, and even if they did, they wouldn’t want me to pay it back.  Those people are beautiful.  They are perfect friends.  They know how I operate.”

CALLER #4: “But didn’t you just say you are not involved in your business?”

TRUMP: “I’m not involved in my business!  My sons run it.  They are really smart, like I am.  They know what I would do.”

CALLER #4: “How do they know?”

TRUMP: “They ask me, stupid.  Next caller.”

CALLER #5: “What do you think of your daughter Ivanka and Jared Kushner going up to your Bedminster golf club for Passover weekend in spite of travel restrictions?”

TRUMP: “You’re a terrible caller! Be nice!  The travel ban doesn’t apply to my family.  There are no rules for me and my family because I am the president, and I make the rules.  When the Senate exonerated me, they gave me permission to do whatever I want.”

CALLER #5: “But what about the Constitution?”

TRUMP: “A tiny technicality.  I let Bill Barr interpret the Constitution.  That’s his job?  My job is to lead this country in the war against this flu bug and to get the country back to work and spending money as soon as possible.”

CALLER #5: “But you just gave the state governors the go-ahead to make the calls as to when to go back to work.”

TRUMP: “Yes, exactly.  Let’s get back to work because that’s what Fox News wants us to do.  Sean Hannity knows best.  Next caller.”

CALLER #6: “Thanks for taking my call.  I had to call to thank you, Mr. President.  You’re doing a bang-up job.”

TRUMP: “Yes, I am.  Thanks for calling, Steve.”

Emperor Trump: Let Them Watch ‘Celebrity Apprentice’

President-elect Donald Trump will continue to be an Executive Producer of the NBC prime-time reality program “The Celebrity Apprentice,” which is returning January 2 after being off the air for two years and will feature a new host, Arnold Schwarzenegger.

When I read this announcement, I was reminded of Emperor Charles-Louis Napoleon Bonaparte, Napoleon III, who once proclaimed, “One of the first duties of a sovereign is to amuse his subjects of all ranks in the social scale.”  According to Ross King, author of the superb book The Judgment of Paris: The Revolutionary Decade That Gave The World Impressionism:

If [Louis-Napoleon’s] subjects could be entertained, he reasoned, then perhaps they would fail to notice or to care about the fact that most of their liberties had vanished. This was the man, after all, who had suppressed an insurrection in Algeria in 1856 by sending the magician Robert Houdin to Algiers to to bamboozle the locals with this repertoire of amazing tricks, including his famous “bullet catch” routine. And what worked on unruly Algerians would likewise, Louis-Napoleon hoped, work for the unruly French.

While President-elect Trump hasn’t yet suppressed journalists and forbidden the press to publish negative comments or images of him as Louis-Napoleon did, I have no doubt that he would like to divert the public’s attention away from such issues as the environment, conflicts of interests and picks of unqualified cabinet officers, and to keep his celebrity, reality star status and image with his core fans and followers. Also, as John Cassidy pointed out in his penetrating New Yorker article, Trump wants to have his cake and eat it too — govern the country and be involved in his businesses. Trump has said that he will have no involvement in making decisions on Celebrity Apprentice and that the Executive Producer title merely represents his development of the show and his financial interest in it.

From Trump’s perspective, there’s no conflict of interest. He’ll get richer and his fans will love him.

In terms of today’s TV network business and ethical values, NBC apparently sees nothing wrong with the president of the United States being listed as an executive producer in one of their entertainment programs. However, I think NBC should be concerned.

Remember CBS’s CEO Les Moonves’s comment about Donald Trump’s campaign? “It might not be good for American, but it’s damn good for CBS.” That was also the attitude of CNN, MSNBC, Fox News — get the ratings from covering Trump regardless of whether it’s good for the country. Profits before public service.

Julian Goodman was President of NBC from 1966-1974, and had come out of the news division. It was under Goodman’s leadership that NBC developed the highly rated Huntley-Brinkley Report that featured John Chancellor, who in 1970 became the sole anchor of the renamed NBC Nightly News, followed by Tom Brokaw. Goodman, Huntley, Brinkley, Chancellor and Brokaw were old-fashioned broadcast newspeople who, like their competitors at CBS News, Edward R. Murrow, Eric Sevareid and Walter Cronkite, felt that broadcast news was a public service, a public trust.

It wasn’t until 1986 when GE bought NBC and Larry Tisch took over as CEO of CBS (after buying 24.9% of CBS’ stock) that the two networks’ news divisions had to make a profit. The notion of news programs making a profit had been anathema to William S. Paley and Robert Sarnoff, the founders of CBS and NBC, who both viewed their news divisions as crown jewels of public service that helped them keep their valuable radio and TV station licenses that were issued by the FCC to “serve the public interest, convenience and necessity.”

I don’t believe that if Julian Goodman, or David Brinkley, or Chet Huntley, or John Chancellor, or Tom Brokaw or their intellectual and public-service/public-trust oriented successors were still running NBC that they would have agreed to carry a program for which one of the executive producers was the president of the United States. Therefore, I don’t blame Donald Trump for taking the executive producer money; I fault NBC for giving it to him.

NBC is helping Trump entertain the public and divert their attention from important issues.

On the other hand, NBC carries Saturday Night Live and Alex Baldwin’s devastatingly satirical impression of our future president, so maybe the scale is somewhat balanced.

Stop Me Before I Kill Again

The following headline was on The Huffington Post on Monday, February15: “Donald Trump Points to Snow Storms, Calls for Al Gore to Be Stripped of Nobel Prize.”
Thus, Trump proves he knows as much about climate change as he does about running casinos or having meaningful relationships with women. His knowledge in these areas rivals the expertise and intellectual depth of Sarah Palin on foreign policy and geography.
Why does the media continue to give publicity and celebrity status to Trump and Palin? The answer is the ultimate example of circular and media logic. They get headlines because they are famous, and they are famous because they get headlines.
Fame gets you on television, which in turn, gets you more famous – the celebrity circle.
Thus, their goal is not accomplishment, productivity, creativity, excellence, humor, expertise, or contribution to humanity, but to get headlines and to be famous.
Fame got Trump a prime-time television program on NBC (and we know how much that helped NBC, which owner GE is trying to palm it off on Comcast) and fame got Palin a gig as a commentator on Fox News.
Sarah Palin is imminently qualified to be on Fox News; she’s got a pretty face and nice hair, which probably explains why Donald Trump doesn’t have a gig on Fox News and might well explain why NBC eventually canceled “The Apprentice.”
What should the media do to stop creating these shallow monsters of fame? They should stop publicizing them, stop giving air time and ink to them.
So stop me from writing before I kill again.